• claptrap (12/12) Sep 02 2024 Seems like an oversight?
• RazvanN (7/19) Sep 03 2024 As per the docs [1]: "If at the declaration level, it affects the
• Johan (6/26) Sep 03 2024 I consider this a bug. Note there is no semicolon after the
• Walter Bright (2/3) Sep 03 2024 Please submit bugs to bugzilla!

claptrap <clap trap.com> writes:

Seems like an oversight?

```d
int Foo()
{
     pragma(inline,true)
     int GetFoo() { return 42; }
     return GetFoo();
}
```

GetFoo isn't inlined, but inlines OK if you pass -inline to the 
compiler

Also inlines OK if you define GetFoo outside of Foo

RazvanN <razvan.nitu1305 gmail.com> writes:

On Monday, 2 September 2024 at 22:16:53 UTC, claptrap wrote:
 Seems like an oversight?

 ```d
 int Foo()
 {
     pragma(inline,true)
     int GetFoo() { return 42; }
     return GetFoo();
 }
 ```

 GetFoo isn't inlined, but inlines OK if you pass -inline to the 
 compiler

 Also inlines OK if you define GetFoo outside of Foo

As per the docs [1]: "If at the declaration level, it affects the 
functions declared in the block it controls. If inside a 
function, it affects the function it is enclosed by". So you 
probably just need to put the pragma(inline) in GetFoo.

RazvanN

[1] https://dlang.org/spec/pragma.html#inline

Johan <j j.nl> writes:

On Tuesday, 3 September 2024 at 14:05:40 UTC, RazvanN wrote:
 On Monday, 2 September 2024 at 22:16:53 UTC, claptrap wrote:
 Seems like an oversight?

 ```d
 int Foo()
 {
     pragma(inline,true)
     int GetFoo() { return 42; }
     return GetFoo();
 }
 ```

 GetFoo isn't inlined, but inlines OK if you pass -inline to 
 the compiler

 Also inlines OK if you define GetFoo outside of Foo

 As per the docs [1]: "If at the declaration level, it affects 
 the functions declared in the block it controls. If inside a 
 function, it affects the function it is enclosed by". So you 
 probably just need to put the pragma(inline) in GetFoo.

I consider this a bug. Note there is no semicolon after the 
pragma, so it is at declaration level (declaration of `GetFoo`).
In the test case, current frontend applies the pragma to `Foo` 
which I think is wrong (because no semicolon after the pragma).

-Johan

Walter Bright <newshound2 digitalmars.com> writes:

On 9/3/2024 10:16 AM, Johan wrote:
 I consider this a bug.

Please submit bugs to bugzilla!