www.digitalmars.com         C & C++   DMDScript  

digitalmars.D.bugs - [Issue 20816] New: this template parameter does not work on static


          Issue ID: 20816
           Summary: this template parameter does not work on static method
           Product: D
           Version: D2
          Hardware: All
                OS: All
            Status: NEW
          Severity: enhancement
          Priority: P1
         Component: dmd
          Assignee: nobody puremagic.com
          Reporter: destructionator gmail.com

Consider the following:

class A {
        static void one() {
                pragma(msg, typeof(this));

        static void two(this This)() {


void main() {

It currently does:

$ dmd pow
pow.d(13): Error: template pow.A.two cannot deduce function from argument types
!()(), candidates are:
pow.d(6):        two(this This)()

(please note it does the same thing if I use an A instance instead of the type
specifically, e.g. `A a; a.one(); a.two();` does the same error.)

I vacillated on if this is a bug or if it isn't supposed to work at all. The
spec says: "TemplateThisParameters are used in member function templates to
pick up the type of the this reference."

Now, you're probably thinking "lol silly adam, it is static so there is no
`this` reference". But that's why I put the method `one` in there - there is a
`this` reference and the compiler knows its type in the normal case. Of course
*using* the `this` reference yields the error "this is only defined in
non-static member functions", so I grant there is some ambiguity, but the type
does clearly exist and the template is really only interested in that static

Moreover, precisely because template this parameters work strictly via the
static type anyway, it needs no dynamic information so there's no theoretical
reason I can think of why it shouldn't work.

Thus, since the spec is silent on there existing any other exceptions to the
rule, I deem that this *should* work per the spec and thus qualifies as an
implementation issue, though since there is some ambiguity in the precise
meaning of "this reference" in the spec text, I classified it as an enhancement
rather than a normal bug per se.

Note that if there were `class B : A {}`, then `B.two();` should also work and
`is(This == B)` ought to pass inside the `A.two` template implementation.

May 09 2020