• Kagamin <spam here.lot> Apr 04 2011
• Matthias Pleh <jens konrad.net> Apr 05 2011
• Kagamin <spam here.lot> Apr 05 2011

Kagamin <spam here.lot> writes:

Matthias Pleh Wrote:

 This were the requirments for the GUI library:
 - Corss-platform (Win/linux)
 - not just a port, but adjusted to the language
 - mostly written in this language, so you can easy debug the lib,
    this means no wrapper library, just system libraries
    (Though gtk+ on linux would hold as a system library so GtkD for 
 linux would be OK, but not on Windows!
 - obviously suitable license for a commercial product
 
 Unfortunately All known GUI-libraries for D fails on this requirments
 So the choice has fallen to C++/Qt


Qt doesn't fulfill the requirement for "just system libraries".

Matthias Pleh <jens konrad.net> writes:

Am 05.04.2011 08:20, schrieb Kagamin:
 Matthias Pleh Wrote:

 This were the requirments for the GUI library:
 - Corss-platform (Win/linux)
 - not just a port, but adjusted to the language
 - mostly written in this language, so you can easy debug the lib,
     this means no wrapper library, just system libraries
     (Though gtk+ on linux would hold as a system library so GtkD for
 linux would be OK, but not on Windows!
 - obviously suitable license for a commercial product

 Unfortunately All known GUI-libraries for D fails on this requirments
 So the choice has fallen to C++/Qt


 Qt doesn't fulfill the requirement for "just system libraries".


<quote>
This were the requirments for the GUI library:
</quote>

Qt is here not the requirement, but rather the GUI library itself

Kagamin <spam here.lot> writes:

Matthias Pleh Wrote:

 Am 05.04.2011 08:20, schrieb Kagamin:
 Matthias Pleh Wrote:

 This were the requirments for the GUI library:
 - Corss-platform (Win/linux)
 - not just a port, but adjusted to the language
 - mostly written in this language, so you can easy debug the lib,
     this means no wrapper library, just system libraries
     (Though gtk+ on linux would hold as a system library so GtkD for
 linux would be OK, but not on Windows!
 - obviously suitable license for a commercial product

 Unfortunately All known GUI-libraries for D fails on this requirments
 So the choice has fallen to C++/Qt


 Qt doesn't fulfill the requirement for "just system libraries".


 <quote>
 This were the requirments for the GUI library:
 </quote>
 
 Qt is here not the requirement, but rather the GUI library itself


I mean, Qt fails on these requirements just like any other GUI library.