• strtr <strtr sp.am> Jun 24 2010
• Jesse Phillips <jessekphillips+D gmail.com> Jun 24 2010
• strtr <strtr sp.am> Jun 24 2010

strtr <strtr sp.am> writes:

In relation to the recently decease request:
How much of D1 won't compile on D2?
Is there a D1-to-D2 guide and how about a comparison chart?
Is D2 worse as a first language, difficulty wise?
Or is maybe the D2 safe subset a good first language?

Jesse Phillips <jessekphillips+D gmail.com> writes:

strtr Wrote:

 In relation to the recently decease request:
 How much of D1 won't compile on D2?
 Is there a D1-to-D2 guide and how about a comparison chart?


There is a page that covers the language changes from D1 to D2[1] Which
actually points to a Migration Page[2] which I have not seen before.

 Is D2 worse as a first language, difficulty wise?
 Or is maybe the D2 safe subset a good first language?


I would say the only complication that would be an issue as a first language is
the transitive cost, immutable. Even then these can be safely ignored.
Understanding use of the standard library might be considered another issue,
but it is common for tutorials to just gloss over the details and say "just do
it this way for now."

I think D2 is a much better language and D1 to be a language that can compete
with other languages. D2 has the issue of limited library support, but if
you're someone who needs an existing library D1 isn't likely to be your
language with that library.  I.e. someone new to the community who wants to get
something done isn't likely to find what they need in D2 or D1.

1. http://www.digitalmars.com/d/2.0/features2.html
2. http://www.digitalmars.com/d/2.0/D1toD2.html

strtr <strtr sp.am> writes:

== Quote from Jesse Phillips (jessekphillips+D gmail.com)'s article
 strtr Wrote:
 In relation to the recently decease request:
 How much of D1 won't compile on D2?
 Is there a D1-to-D2 guide and how about a comparison chart?




 Is D2 worse as a first language, difficulty wise?
 Or is maybe the D2 safe subset a good first language?




Understanding use of the standard library might be considered another issue, but
it is common for tutorials to just gloss over the details and say "just do it
this
way for now."
 I think D2 is a much better language and D1 to be a language that can compete


someone who needs an existing library D1 isn't likely to be your language with
that library.  I.e. someone new to the community who wants to get something done
isn't likely to find what they need in D2 or D1.
 1. http://www.digitalmars.com/d/2.0/features2.html
 2. http://www.digitalmars.com/d/2.0/D1toD2.html


Nice, I hadn't seen that D1toD2 one.
Reads like it could be automated btw.